Marta Bosquet, elegida primera Defensora del Pueblo Andaluz

Date of article: 11/11/2026

Daily News of: 13/11/2026

Country:  Spain - Andalusia

Author:

Article language: es

El Pleno del Parlamento de Andalucía ha elegido a Marta Bosquet Aznar como Defensora del Pueblo Andaluz.

Bosquet, que obtuvo 66 votos a favor y alcanzó la mayoría de tres quintos exigida para su elección, será la primera mujer en ocupar el cargo desde la creación de la institución en diciembre de 1983. El mandato tendrá una duración de cinco años.

Al término de la votación, la presidenta del Parlamento de Andalucía, Ana Mestre, se refirió a la responsabilidad que asume Bosquet como «una etapa preciosa» para representar los intereses de todos los andaluces, «sobre todo los más vulnerables».

Mestre también agradeció a Jesús Maeztu el trabajo realizado al frente de la Defensoría y destacó que ha desempeñado «una magnífica labor». Maeztu concluye una etapa de más de trece años al frente de la institución, a la que llegó en 2013 y en la que permanecía en funciones desde 2024, tras una primera experiencia en la década de los 90.

Tras su elección, Bosquet afirmó en redes sociales que supone un «grandísimo honor» y se comprometió a ejercer la responsabilidad con honestidad, independencia, objetividad y la máxima entrega a la ciudadanía. «Voy a ser firme con las administraciones, recta con el derecho», pero sobre todo, a ejercer el cargo «con una enorme humanidad».

Bosquet expresó su voluntad de ponerse al servicio de toda la ciudadanía, con especial atención a las personas en situación de vulnerabilidad, a quienes carecen de voz o permanecen invisibilizados y a la infancia. «Prometo ser la Defensora de todo el Pueblo Andaluz», afirmó.

Nacida en Almería en 1969, Marta Bosquet es licenciada en Derecho por la Universidad de Granada y ejerció la abogacía durante dos décadas. Fue diputada por Almería, presidió la Comisión de Justicia en la X Legislatura y ocupó la Presidencia del Parlamento de Andalucía entre 2018 y 2022.

Read more

The Ombudsman’s position on the proposed amendment to the Protection of Public Order Act concerning the recognisability of persons in public places

Date of article: 12/11/2026

Daily News of: 13/11/2026

Country:  Slovenia

Author:

Article language: en

The Human Rights Ombudsman of the Republic of Slovenia (the Ombudsman) understands from the press release issued by the Government of the Republic of Slovenia on 5 November 2026 regarding its 18th regular session[1] that, among other things, it adopted an opinion on the Proposal to call a consultative referendum on the prohibition of face covering in public places, which had been submitted to the National Assembly of the Republic of Slovenia by a group of Members of Parliament, and also approved the text of the draft Act Amending the Protection of Public Order Act, proposing the enactment of a new article stipulating that a person in a public place must have their face uncovered so that their facial features are recognizable; this proposal is to be submitted to the National Assembly of the Republic of Slovenia for consideration under the shortened legislative procedure.

As is well known, in accordance with the Referendum and Popular Initiative Act (ZRLI)[2], the National Assembly may call a consultative referendum on matters within its remit that are of broader significance to citizens before making a final decision on a particular issue; however, it is not otherwise bound by the outcome of such a referendum. Without delving further into the anticipated developments in this regard, it is in any case worth recalling that, in accordance with the Rules of Procedure of the National Assembly (PoDZ-1), the National Assembly has a Legislative and Legal Service, which issues opinions on the conformity of draft laws and amendments with the Constitution and the legal system, as well as on the legislative and technical aspects of the proposals. For its part, the Ombudsman takes this opportunity to set out its position on the aforementioned legislative proposal, as published on the website[3] of the Government of the Republic of Slovenia.

The Draft Act Amending the Protection of Public Order Act (draft EVA reference No. 2026-1720-0036, hereinafter referred to as the amendment to ZJRM-2) provides for a new Article 9a (Identifiability of a person in a public place), the first paragraph of which stipulates: “Any person who is present or moving about in a public place must have their face uncovered in such a way that their facial features can be recognized.” The second paragraph of the same article stipulates that the first paragraph of this article shall not apply where covering the face is necessary for medical reasons, the performance of a profession or work, artistic, cultural or traditional events, or sporting activities. The third paragraph of the same article, however, provides for a fine for a breach of the first paragraph.

The proposer explains that the purpose of the provision is to enable the recognition of the facial features of persons who are present or moving about in a public place, thereby contributing to the maintenance of public safety and more effective identification in circumstances where this is necessary; that this introduces into the legal system the principle of recognizing individuals in public spaces as one of the aspects of ensuring public order and safety and the effective performance of the duties of the competent authorities; that the provision contributes to the achievement of the legitimate aim of safeguarding public order and peace, preventing minor and criminal offences, and enabling the identification of persons in cases specified by law; that it is based on the premise that the recognizability of individuals in public spaces is one of the conditions for the effective functioning of the rule of law and for ensuring the safety of people and property; that the proposed regulation is of a general and neutral nature, applying to all persons present in or moving through public places; that the provision does not prohibit the wearing of specific items of clothing or other forms of self-expression, but only the covering of the face to the extent that it prevents the recognizability of facial features, therefore, it does not interfere with any particular form of personal expression, but regulates conduct in public places in order to protect the public interest; and that the first paragraph stipulates that a person must have their face uncovered to such an extent that their facial features can be recognized, the decisive factor being is the effect of the covering, not the type of garment or other object used to cover the face.

Furthermore, the explanatory memorandum to the proposal clarifies that, to ensure compliance with the principle of proportionality, the proposal also contains statutory exceptions where face covering is objectively justified; that the second paragraph sets out cases in which the obligation under the first paragraph does not apply, namely in cases where covering the face is necessary for medical reasons, the performance of a profession or work, participation in artistic, cultural or traditional events, or the practice of sporting activities, thereby allowing the face to be covered in circumstances where this is justified by the nature of the activity or specific needs; and so that account is taken of circumstances in which a general requirement to uncover the face would be disproportionate or would unjustifiably interfere with the rights or legitimate interests of individuals.

The Ombudsman’s position in principle is that a statutory prohibition on face covering is not necessarily, in itself, ununconstitutional or incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights. With regard to the specific legislative solution, as it appears to be planned, it should first be recalled that Human Rights Ombudswoman Dr Simona Drenik Bavdek, has on several occasions[4] publicly called on all decision-makers to use the ordinary legislative procedure, which allows for adequate timeframes for expert consideration, public participation and the prudent adoption of legislative solutions. Shortened and other exceptional legislative procedures should remain reserved for circumstances that genuinely justify such treatment. Indeed, the hasty adoption of legislation may diminish the level of democratic debate, affect the quality of regulations and increase the risk of constitutionally impermissible or disproportionate interference with fundamental rights.

Where the legislature intervenes in the sphere of constitutionally guaranteed human rights, it is particularly important that the reasons for any restrictions are clearly substantiated, their consequences carefully weighed up, and that the public is afforded the opportunity for a substantive and inclusive debate. The speed of the legislative process must not take precedence over the quality of the legal framework and the protection of human rights.

Admittedly, the proposed amendment to the ZJRM-2 does indeed contain only three articles and, from a quantitative perspective, may at first glance appear to be a ‘less demanding amendment and supplement to the Act’, as it ‘merely’ establishes the obligation for a person to be recognizable in a public place, but in substance, this undoubtedly constitutes an important issue for society concerning the exercise of human rights and fundamental freedoms, such as the general freedom of conduct, which derives from the protection of privacy and personality rights (Article 35 of the Constitution of the Republic of Slovenia (URS)), freedom of expression (Article 39 of the URS) and also freedom of religion (Article 41 of the URS).

The Ombudsman therefore draws particular attention to the importance of a high-quality and inclusive legislative process. A proposal that raises questions regarding the exercise of several constitutionally guaranteed human rights and fundamental freedoms requires a particularly careful expert and public debate, as well as a thorough assessment of its potential consequences and the reasons for its adoption. General assessments, such as those set out in the explanatory memorandum to the draft Act, which do not contain specific data, cannot be sufficiently convincing. Indeed, it is not clear from the explanatory memorandum what actual risks to public safety the proposed legislation is intended to eliminate; consequently, it is not possible to assess whether the objective pursued by it is even achievable.

The Ombudsman therefore fails to identify convincing reasons as to why the proposed amendments to the ZJRM-2 should not be considered under the ordinary legislative procedure, which would ensure all procedural safeguards in the consideration of such an important social issue relating to the realization of the human rights and fundamental freedoms of the inhabitants of the Republic of Slovenia.

From a substantive perspective, however, the Ombudsman wishes to draw particular attention to the issue of the lack of clarity of the proposed provisions. (Article 2 of the Constitution[5]). The proposed wording currently states that ‘any person who is present or moving about in a public place must have their face uncovered in such a way that their facial features can be recognized’. Particularly from the perspective of respect for the requirements of legal certainty and legality (Articles 2 and 28[6] of the Constitution), the very fact that ‘facial features’ is a rather broad and insufficiently defined legal term[7] may already be problematic. Consequently, it is unclear which parts of the face would be prohibited from being covered in public places, nor is it entirely clear under what circumstances, as the exceptions are listed exhaustively. For example, will wearing sunglasses in public places now constitute a prohibited covering of facial features (the eyes), or will covering the mouth and nose with a scarf in winter also be prohibited or subject to sanctions following this amendment? Would a doctor have to prescribe or authorize the wearing of sunglasses, a scarf or a mask for this to constitute a legally permissible exception? How will the length and grooming of a man’s beard be dealt with? The law must, after all, be applied without discrimination and equally to everyone and in all situations not specified as exceptions.

At the same time, an unclear provision carries the risk of arbitrary decision-making in its application. As the law does not specify when covering facial features is permissible and when it is not, the assessment of whether an offence has been committed will, in practice, be left to the individual police officer on the ground, who will have to decide for themselves whether sunglasses, a scarf or a beard still prevent facial recognition. Such broad discretion increases the risk of unequal treatment in similar cases and of the prohibition being enforced in an impermissibly selective manner, particularly against individuals who, due to their appearance, religion or other personal circumstances – including political beliefs – are more conspicuous. On the other hand, from the perspective of predictability, it is also not entirely clear whether an individual can reasonably foresee which conduct is prohibited. The statutory provision must therefore be drafted in such a way as to afford the individual reasonable predictability, while providing law enforcement authorities with sufficient criteria for uniform and non-arbitrary application. With regard to arbitrariness, reference should also be made, for example, to point 7 of the decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Slovenia, No. Up-332/98-23, dated 18 April 2002, which states, among other things: ‘Regardless of which provision defines an offence, the principle of lex certa must also be respected when formulating the rules defining offences – a provision defining a certain act as punishable must be predetermined, clear and predictable. The Constitutional Court had already, in Decision No. U-I-213/98 of 16 March 2000 (Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, No. 33/2000 and OdlUS IX, 50) that the requirement for a precise definition of criminal conduct must also be respected when defining administrative offences. The purpose of this requirement is to ensure that the perpetrator knows in advance what constitutes a punishable offence and is aware that they are committing an act defined as such. The purpose of the principle of legality – and thus of specificity – in substantive criminal law is to prevent the arbitrary and capricious application of state punitive sanctions in situations that have not been precisely defined in advance (Decision No. U-I-6/93 of 1 April 1994, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, No. 23/94 and OdlUS III, 33). Only a command or prohibition that is foreseen in advance and precisely defined can effectively deter its violation (Decision No. U-I-183/96 of 16 July 1998, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, No. 56/98 and OdlUS VII, 146). A provision establishing a punishable offence meets these requirements if the content of the prohibited conduct can be ascertained using established methods of interpretation, and the conduct of the authorities responsible for enforcing it is thereby defined and predictable.’ Everything stated so far therefore applies all the more so because the matter in question falls within the field of the law governing punitive sanctions, where the requirement of precision is of key importance and must be consistently observed (nullum crimen, nulla poena sine lege certa).

The Ombudsman is, furthermore, particularly critical of the proposer’s position as set out in the explanatory memorandum to the proposed amendment, where it is stated that ‘the provision does not prohibit the wearing of specific items of clothing or other forms of identity expression, but only the covering of the face to the extent that it prevents the recognizability of facial features, and therefore does not interfere with any particular form of personal expression, but regulates behaviour in public places in order to protect the public interest’. It is a fact that the wearing of clothing, head coverings, spectacles and masks, as well as the wearing of a beard may constitute a form of personal expression, an expression of an individual’s identity, and may also reflect religious beliefs. These aspects of identity expression may be protected within the framework of human rights and fundamental freedoms. This also follows from the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter: the ECtHR), which has treated the choice of clothing and personal appearance either as a manifestation of religion under Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) (e.g. Ahmet Arslan and Others v. Turkey, 2010; Eweida and Others v. the United Kingdom, 2013) or as part of private life under Article 8 of the ECHR (e.g. Biržietis v. Lithuania, 2016). In the explanatory memorandum to the proposed amendment, the Ombudsman therefore finds it particularly regrettable that the proposer has not specifically acknowledged that the proposed amendments interfere with human rights and fundamental freedoms.

On this occasion, it is also worth reiterating the Ombudsman’s long-standing recommendation to the Government that it should establish a central point of contact within each ministry to assess the compliance of regulations or measures with human rights and fundamental freedoms, and that it should include a mandatory explanatory note in government documents regarding the regulation: ‘Compliance of the regulation with human rights and fundamental freedoms.’ (Ombudsman’s Annual Report for 2021, Recommendation No. 1, p. 62). In the specific case of this draft bill, in which a single provision interferes with several human rights and fundamental freedoms, the great need for an assessment of the regulation’s impact on human rights is therefore very clearly demonstrated. Such an assessment would have several positive effects – it would enable the proposer to minimize the risk of potential legal proceedings arising from human rights violations, while ensuring that those affected are afforded a careful assessment of the legislator’s interference with their human rights right from the legislative drafting stage.

Having reviewed the draft amendment to the Act, the Ombudsman also notes that, while the proposer of the amendment does not cite specific case law of the ECtHR, they do refer to it in general terms. In this regard, it is particularly worth noting that, in its 2014 judgment in the case of S.A.S. v. France, the ECtHR ruled that the French general ban on face coverings in public places did not constitute a violation of the ECHR. In doing so, it took into account the protection of the conditions for ‘living together’ in society as a legitimate aim. It adopted a similar position in the subsequent case of Dakir v. Belgium in 2017. This case law therefore shows that such restrictions are not, in themselves, incompatible with European standards of human rights protection. However, this does not mean that every general prohibition is automatically constitutionally permissible. A specific statutory provision must be assessed in terms of its aim, scope, justification and proportionality, taking into account the Slovenian constitutional order. In doing so, the principle of equality set out in the first paragraph of Article 14 of the Constitution and the prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion or belief, which is regulated in more detail by the Protection Against Discrimination Act (ZVarD), must also be taken into account. Therefore, in the Ombudsman’s view, it is essential that the proposer clearly defines the legitimate aim of the restriction and demonstrates that the interference with human rights is appropriate, necessary and proportionate.

With regard to the definition of a legitimate aim and the proposer’s assertion that the obligation to reveal one’s facial features in a public place pursues the aim of ensuring public safety and more effective identification, we wish to point out that the ECtHR, in the aforementioned case of S.A.S. v. France, stated (paragraph 139), “that it cannot be concluded that the general ban laid down by the Law of 11 October 2010 is necessary in a democratic society for the purposes of public safety within the meaning of Articles 8 and 9 of the Convention”. A general ban on face covering for the purpose of ensuring public safety was therefore not recognized as necessary in a democratic society in this case, even though the Court did recognize public safety as a legitimate aim. It should therefore be reconsidered whether the proposed legislation is truly necessary to achieve this objective, or whether, in view of the stated objective and purpose of the proposed amendment to the Act, an obligation to temporarily uncover one’s face for identification purposes would, for example, suffice. Particularly in the case of a general ban that would apply in all public places, it is therefore necessary to carefully consider whether the stated objective cannot be achieved by less restrictive, more targeted measures than those currently proposed. In this context, the question also arises as to whether the exhaustively listed exceptions in the proposed second paragraph of Article 9a of the amendment are in fact all the exceptions envisaged by the proposer and are proportionate and necessary in a democratic society, or whether it might nevertheless be worth considering, from the perspective of legal certainty and the clarity of the legislation, the inclusion of at least a few further exceptions, such as those relating to specific weather conditions (sun, severe cold, wind) or religious sites in accordance with religious customs.

With regard to the infringements of human rights envisaged by the proposed legislation, we wish to particularly highlight the issue of wearing clothing through which an individual complies with religious rules, which falls within the scope of freedom of conscience or religion under Article 41 of the Constitution. In paragraph 84 of the grounds for its decision No. U-I-92/07 of 15 April 2010, the Constitutional Court has already explained that positive freedom of religion also protects conduct that constitutes compliance with religious rules, including the wearing of religious clothing and symbols. The Ombudsman has no data or analyses available suggesting that the covering of the face for religious reasons in Slovenia poses such a threat to public safety, health or the rights of others as to justify, in itself, a general statutory prohibition. This does not mean, however, that restrictions might not be justified in specific circumstances. The Ombudsman emphasizes that the wearing of religious clothing may be an expression of an individual’s religious beliefs and personal choice and, as such, enjoys constitutional protection. At the same time, freedom of religion is not an absolute right. As is apparent from paragraph 93 of the grounds for the aforementioned decision of the Constitutional Court and the third paragraph of Article 15 of the Constitution, restrictions on it are permissible under certain conditions.

The question of the performance of religious rites in places of worship also remains unresolved, as these are, as a rule, public places within the meaning of Article 2 of the ZJRM-2, which stipulates that a public place is ‘any space that is unconditionally or subject to certain conditions accessible to everyone and does not constitute a cyberspace as defined in the law governing information security’, which means that the aforementioned prohibition could particularly affect the performance of, or access to, religious ceremonies for women or a specific population group.

The Ombudsman is also critical of the proposer’s position as set out in the explanatory memorandum to the draft amendment, specifically the statement that “the proposed regulation is of a general and neutral nature, applying to all persons who are present in or moving through public places”, as it appears that, when drafting the explanatory memorandum, an important group of residents of the Republic of Slovenia was overlooked, a group which could be disproportionately affected by the proposed regulation due to their personal circumstances (e.g. religion, gender). We wish to point out that a regulation of a ‘general and neutral nature’ is not, in itself, necessarily non-discriminatory. [8]

The first paragraph of Article 14 of the Constitution (equality before the law) guarantees everyone the same human rights and fundamental freedoms, regardless of nationality, race, gender, language, religion or other personal circumstances (prohibition of discrimination). State authorities are bound by the Protection Against Discrimination Act (ZVarD); namely, state authorities must, in all areas of decision-making, in their legal dealings and in all other activities or conduct in relation to third parties, ensure protection against discrimination and equal treatment of all persons (first paragraph of Article 2 of the ZVarD). The ZVarD prohibits discrimination (second paragraph of Article 4 of the ZVarD), explicitly including discrimination on the grounds of nationality, sex and religion (Article 1 of the ZVarD). The ZVarD prohibits both direct and indirect forms of discrimination. The latter exists where a person or group of persons with a particular personal circumstance has been, is or could be placed at a disadvantage compared with others by an apparently neutral provision, criterion or practice, unless that provision, criterion or practice is objectively based on a legitimate aim and the means of achieving that aim are appropriate and necessary (second paragraph of Article 6 of the ZVarD).

The ECtHR, too, found in the aforementioned case of S.A.S. v. France that the law in question makes no mention of religion and is drafted in a neutral manner. However, despite its apparent neutrality, it could be indirectly discriminatory, as the ban has specific negative effects on Muslim women who, for religious reasons, wear a full-face veil (paragraph 161 of the judgment in the case of S.A.S. v. France; the negative impact of the ban on these women is also discussed in paragraph 146). The Court therefore assessed the issue as indirect discrimination, in accordance with the doctrine established in cases such as D.H. v. the Czech Republic. According to this doctrine, a general policy or measure that disproportionately affects a particular group may be regarded as discriminatory, even if it is not directed against that group. In view of the above, therefore, the proposed amendment to the ZJRM-2 also highlights the need to assess the compatibility of the proposed ban on concealing facial features with the right to freedom of religion and the prohibition of discrimination.

Taking all of the above into account, the Ombudsman, with a view to future decision-making on the current proposed amendment to the ZJRM-2, proposes that the scope of the proposed ban on covering facial features in public places be recognized, in particular the various aspects of interference with several human rights (Articles 35, 39, 41 and 14 of the Constitution); that, on this basis, an assessment be carried out of the provision’s compliance with all the aforementioned human rights and fundamental freedoms; that it be reassessed whether the proposed measure is truly necessary to achieve the intended objective, to examine the possibility of adopting less restrictive measures to achieve it, and to assess whether certain groups of the population might be disproportionately affected due to their personal circumstances (religion, gender); that particular attention be paid to the issue of the specificity of the phrase ‘facial features’, including a careful examination of all possible real-life examples (sunglasses, scarves, face masks, men’s beards, etc.); and that, given the significance of this social issue relating to the realization of human rights and fundamental freedoms, the amendment be considered under the ordinary legislative procedure, where provision should be made for a thorough expert and public debate, as well as a careful assessment of the grounds for its adoption and the potential consequences of implementing the proposed legislation.

---------------------------------------------------------

[1] https://www.gov.si/novice/2026-11-05-18-redna-seja-vlade-republike-slovenije/

[2] Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia, Nos. 26/07 – official consolidated text, 6/18 – Constitutional Court decision, 52/20 and 30/24.

[3] https://www.gov.si/drzavni-organi/vlada/seje-vlade/gradiva-v-obravnavi/show/14453/

[4] See, for example: The Ombudswoman Expresses Concern Over the Proposed Reduction of Procedural Safeguards in Parliamentary Inquiries - Varuh človekovih pravic

[5] The principle of precision of legal provisions (lex certa) is one of the fundamental principles of the rule of law under Article 2 of the Constitution of the Republic of Slovenia. The Constitutional Court has repeatedly emphasised that legal provisions must be formulated clearly and with sufficiently ascertainable meaning to enable their content and purpose to be established, to ensure that they can be implemented and to prevent arbitrary conduct by state authorities. A legislative framework is constitutionally impermissible, in particular, where it exposes those subject to legal provisions to an unacceptable degree of unpredictability and uncertainty regarding the legal consequences of their conduct (Constitutional Court Decision No. U-I-115/23 of 4 April 2024, paragraph 20 of the reasoning; Decision Nos. U-I-49/17 and U-I-98/17 of 28 March 2019, paragraph 18 of the reasoning).

[6] Although the first paragraph of Article 28 of the Constitution of the Republic of Slovenia primarily governs the guarantee of legality in criminal law, the Constitutional Court has expressly held in its established case law that this constitutional guarantee also applies to the law governing minor offences (see, for example, Decision No. Up-548/15 of 17 October 2019, paragraph 12 of the reasoning, and Decision No. U-I-491/18 of 6 May 2021, paragraph 47 of the reasoning).

[7] Furthermore, it is unclear what distinguishes this term from, for example, the term 'facial image', which is used in Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation), the Identity Card Act (ZOIzk-1) and the Foreigners Act (ZTuj-2). Article 41 of the Police Tasks and Powers Act (ZNPPol), for example, refers to a 'person whose face is covered or disguised', while Article 6 of the Rules on Police Powers refers to a 'clearly visible face', etc.

[8] On this occasion, we would also like to recall the Ombudsman's Recommendations Nos. 7, 8 and 9 from the Annual Report for 2022 (pp. 260–261), in which the Ombudsman recommended that an assessment of the potential discriminatory effects of proposed legislation should also be carried out during the legislative drafting process.

Read more

IOI Ombudsman News 43/2026

Date of article: 13/11/2026

Daily News of: 13/11/2026

Country:  WORLD

Author:

Article language: en


 

 


 

The IOI Asian Regional webinar takes place on 17 November 2026

IOI Asia | IOI Asian Regional Webinar 2026

The Asian Secretariat is pleased to invite all interested member institution to the IOI’s Asian Regional Webinar entitled From Principles to Practice: The Ombudsman’s Role in Promoting Good Administration, will take place on Tuesday, 17 November 2026 from 14.30 to 15.45 Bangkok time (UTC +7) per Zoom. Kindly click here for more information.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

APOR President Niki Rattle, Commonwealth Ombudsman Iain Anderson and colleagues at the event

AUSTRALIA | Commonwealth Ombudsman – Host of 38th Australasia Pacific Ombudsman Region (APOR) Conference and Meeting

The Office of the Commonwealth Ombudsman was pleased to host the 38th annual Australasian Pacific Ombudsman Region (APOR) Members meeting and Conference in Canberra on 4-5 November 2026, bringing together Ombudsman and representatives from across the region, including APOR President and Cook Islands Ombudsman, Ms Niki Rattle. Under the theme Future Proofing Fairness, the conference provided an opportunity to strengthen regional connections, share practical experiences, and explore how Ombudsman offices can respond to emerging opportunities and challenges.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

Photo de groupe du séminaire conjoint

AOMF | Séminaire conjoint AOMF-AIPPF-APF-OIF, 21-22 octobre à Dakar : Lanceurs d’alerte : quel cadre juridique efficient et protecteur des droits ? Réflexions croisées des médiateurs et des procureurs

Les 21 et 22 octobre 2026, l’Association des Ombudsmans et Médiateurs de la Francophonie (AOMF) et l’Association Internationale des Procureurs et Poursuivants Francophones (AIPPF), l’Assemblée parlementaire de la Francophonie (APF) et l’Organisation internationale de la Francophonie (OIF) se sont réunis à Dakar, dans le cadre d’un séminaire sur le thème : « Lanceurs d’alerte : quel cadre juridique efficient et protecteur des droits ? Réflexions croisées des médiateurs et des procureurs ».



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

 

Pakistan | Ombudsman Sindh Welcomes Ombudsman Punjab and Federal Ombudsperson FOSPAH

Over the past fortnight, the Office of the Provincial Ombudsman Sindh had the honour of hosting Ms. Ayesha Hamid, Ombudsman Punjab, and Ms. Fauzia Viqar, Federal Ombudsperson for Protection against Harassment (FOSPAH), Pakistan. Their engagements with the office brought federal and provincial ombudsman institutions together to share experience and learn from one another’s work.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

 

AUSTRIA | Ombudsperson Achitz reports to UN committee on Austria’s social welfare/needs-based minimum benefit system

The Austrian Ombudsman Board (AOB) plays an active role in the country reviews conducted by the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR). In its capacity as a National Human Rights Institution, it regularly submits reports and raises points of criticism regarding the implementation of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) in Austria. As part of the current country review, the AOB has submitted a comprehensive statement of opinion. Ombudsperson Bernhard Achitz also outlined these points of criticism at a meeting of the Committee on 5 November 2026.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

 

EUROPE | Commission’s refusal to give public access to lithium mining project application is maladministration

European Ombudswoman Teresa Anjinho has said the European Commission’s refusal to give public access to documents related to the application by a lithium mining project in Serbia for fast-track status under the Critical Raw Materials Act is unreasonable and found maladministration. The finding follows two complaints by individuals seeking transparency about how the project in the Jadar Valley of Serbia was assessed and selected to be a ‘strategic project’.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

The Ombudsman's Awards Presentation Ceremony

HONG KONG, CHINA | Ombudsman commends excellent public services with annual awards and calls for joint efforts from departments and organisations to enhance governance effectiveness by putting people first

At the 29th Presentation Ceremony of The Ombudsman’s Awards on 30 October 2026, the Ombudsman, Mr Jack Chan, presented seven Organisation Awards, 84 Awards for Public Officers and 15 Team Awards to recognise the outstanding performance of government departments, public organisations, teams and public officers in various areas. The scale of the Awards was further expanded this year, with a record number of departments, organisations, teams and officers receiving the honours, and an attendance exceeding 480 at the ceremony.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

 

UK | National action needed to improve safety and independence of wheelchair users

The Public Service Ombudsman's report reveals the barriers to effective commissioning of wheelchair services that have left people facing delays of months or even years for vital equipment. It calls on the Government and NHS England to deliver a more consistent, national approach to improve the lives of wheelchair users.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)

 

 

Pakistan | Ombudsman Punjab Secures Rs 9 Million in Educational Scholarships for 65 Students

The timely intervention of the Office of the Ombudsman Punjab has enabled 65 students from across the province to receive outstanding educational scholarships amounting to Rs9 million.



» more information

» google translate (Francais)
» google translate (Español)
Read more

Criticism of the Social Welfare Committee in Vännäs Municipality for failing to implement the intervention personal assistance in the manner the individual was entitled to, and for deficient documentation

Date of article: 06/11/2026

Daily News of: 13/11/2026

Country:  Sweden

Author:

Article language: en

Date of decision: 2026-08-20Decision case number: 8309-2025Decision maker: Thomas Norling

Summary of the decision: An individual was granted personal assistance pursuant to the Act (SFS 1993:387) concerning Support and Service for Persons with Certain Functional Impairments. With reference to, among other issues, recruitment problems, the committee implemented the intervention through a separate home-help group.

Personal assistance is a personalised intervention. The individual must have direct influence over the planning and design of the intervention, as well as its implementation. According to the Parliamentary Ombudsman, it is apparent that the individual has not had any real influence over when and how the intervention was to be implemented, nor has he had adequate control over who was to implement it. By using the home-help group, the committee has failed to provide the personalised support that the intervention personal assistance is intended to be. Nor can home-help personnel be considered personal assistants in the meaning of the Act concerning Support and Service for Persons with Certain Functional Impairments. As such, the Parliamentary Ombudsman states that the individual has not been given access to the intervention he was entitled to. The committee has thus failed to enforce the intervention and is criticised accordingly.

Furthermore, the Parliamentary Ombudsman notes that documentation of the individual’s case is highly deficient and that this has hindered the Parliamentary Ombudsman’s review. The documentation fails to meet the requirements of the Act concerning Support and Service for Persons with Certain Functional Impairments on the documentation of interventions. The committee is also criticised for this.

Date of decision: 2026-08-20

Read more

(CoE) In outsourcing migration management, people’s human rights must never be overlooked

Date of article: 10/11/2026

Daily News of: 13/11/2026

Country:  EUROPE

Author: Commissioner for Human Rights - CoE

Article language: en

In outsourcing migration management, people’s human rights must never be overlooked

The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, Michael O’Flaherty, today issued a set of practical considerations aimed at preventing human rights violations when states engage in external cooperation on migration management.

This self-assessment tool is released as several member states consider policies and external cooperation to shift asylum or return procedures outside their territory, including establishing “return hubs”, or to partner with third countries to prevent irregular border crossings into Europe.

“Externalised migration policies carry human rights risks. As states prepare to launch new initiatives, now is the time for governments to take concrete action to prevent harm. Early scrutiny can reveal systemic weaknesses in cooperation agreements before they lead to violations. That’s why I am calling on states to demonstrate that they can overcome barriers to protect human rights in practice, and, if they are unable to do that, be prepared to step back from their plans,” said Commissioner O’Flaherty.

The publication, External migration policies under the human rights lens: A self-assessment tool, outlines issues that states should address across six key areas. It emphasises the need for governments to assess human rights risks before deciding to engage in migration management cooperation and to adopt adequate measures. It also aims to support transparent, accountable governance and good administration.

While it is the business of states to manage migration, their policies should never expose people to harm or ill-treatment, or deny access to adequate asylum procedures, humane reception conditions, and judicial remedies.

The self-assessment tool asks states to reflect, from the outset, on whether they have:

  • Clearly defined the policy and its implications for people affected;
  • Comprehensively assessed human rights risks;
  • Established effective measures to prevent violations and independent monitoring mechanisms;
  • Planned responses should violations occur; and
  • Ensured transparency, democratic scrutiny and appropriate follow-up.

These practical considerations apply to governments considering new external cooperation on migration as well as to those with existing arrangements. They are relevant for the duration of any cooperation. They build on the Commissioner's September 2025 report, Externalised asylum and migration policies and human rights law, in which he called on states to adopt a precautionary approach.

The Commissioner does not endorse any specific external cooperation activity. States are accountable for fulfilling their human rights obligations. This publication serves to help countries avoid arrangements that conflict with those obligations.

“In outsourcing migration management, people’s human rights must never be overlooked,” Commissioner O’Flaherty said.

Read more

Link to the Ombudsman Daily News archives from 2002 to 20 October 2011