Joint statement of international organizations re. the Office of the Polish Ombudsman

Date of article: 01/03/2016

Daily News of: 03/03/2016

Country:  Poland

Author: Polish Ombudsman

Article language: en

Representatives of global and regional bodies concerned with rule of law and human rights have met in Warsaw with the new Polish Ombudsman, Dr. Adam Bodnar, to discuss the institutional landscape in Poland and the environment in which the Ombudsman’s Office is currently operating.
These bodies were:

  • the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (UNOHCHR), through its Regional Office for Europe;
  •  the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders;
  •  the Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE/ODIHR);
  • the Council of Europe; and
  • the European Network of National Human Rights Institutions (ENNHRI).

The participants recall that the bodies they represent have worked harmoniously with Mr. Bodnar’s predecessors, namely Ms Ewa Letowska, Mr Tadeusz Zielinski, Mr Adam Zielinski, Mr Andrzej Zoll, Mr Janusz Kochanowski and Ms Irena Lipowicz.
They also underline that the institution of the Polish Ombudsman is highly respected among its peers in Europe and beyond. It is considered today by many actors as a model national human rights institution, especially in terms of its independence and professionalism.

They are confident that there is a broad consensus which recognises the benefits of Poland having an institution of this standing which:

  • enjoys independence and functional immunity and which is therefore able to act impartially to safeguard the rights of individuals;
  • ensures the harmonization of national legislation with international human rights instruments;
  • can bring or join cases before the courts of the country, including the Constitutional Tribunal;
  • has been conferred “A” status as an institution acting in full compliance with the UN Paris Principles; and
  • serves as a role model for other similar institutions in Europe and beyond.

They confirm that the bodies they represent look forward to continuing their close cooperation  with the Ombudsman’s institution as it continues to implement its mandate in full compliance with the Paris Principles.

 

Read more

Unterhaltsverfahren nach mehr als vier Jahren immer noch nicht abgeschlossen

Date of article: 02/03/2016

Daily News of: 03/03/2016

Country:  Austria

Author: Austrian Ombudsman Board

Article language: de

Immer wieder wird die Volksanwaltschaft mit Beschwerden über lange Verfahrensdauer konfrontiert. In diesem Fall kritisiert Volksanwältin Brinek die Vorgehensweise besonders scharf: „Gerade in Angelegenheiten, die den Unterhalt minderjähriger Kinder betreffen, ist eine rasche Abhandlung unbedingt nötig.“

Eine vierjährige Verfahrensverzögerung mit einer inhaltlichen Komplexität und einer schwierigen Personalsituation bei Gericht zu erklären, lasse sie nicht gelten. „Auch im Falle von Versetzungen und Abwesenheiten von Diplomrechtspflegerinnen wegen Mutterschutz oder Karenz müssen sich die Betroffenen auf zeitnahe Entscheidungen über ihren Unterhaltsanspruch verlassen können.“

Das BMJ sicherte nach Anfrage der Volksanwaltschaft zu, dem Verfahren von Seiten der Dienstaufsicht verstärkte Aufmerksamkeit zu widmen und auf einen raschen Verfahrensfortgang zu drängen.

Read more

Council needs to review whether children have lost out on school places

Date of article: 03/03/2016

Daily News of: 03/03/2016

Country:  United Kingdom - England

Author: Local Government Ombudsmen for England

Article language: en

Bolton MBC should check whether any children have missed out on a place at their preferred school after the Local Government Ombudsman (LGO) upheld a complaint about its schools allocation process.

A mother, whose son was due to start school in September 2015, contacted the LGO when an appeal about her son’s school place was not upheld.

The investigation found Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council changed the way it decided schools admissions mid-way through the application process, and without consulting people.

The council uses distance from the chosen school as the main criterion. Previously, where there was a tie for a place it would allocate any remaining places to those children whose alternate school would be the greatest distance from their homes. However, midway through the round of allocations in December 2014 – seven months too late - the council decided to simply draw lots to determine the places.

The LGO investigation found fault with the way the council changed its admissions arrangements.

In the individual case, the investigation found the council was at fault for allocating the children a place by drawing lots. However, it was clear that the boy would not have been allocated a place at the school requested even if the proper process has been followed.

Dr Jane Martin, Local Government Ombudsman, said:

“When making changes to policies which affect a wide number of people it is only right and fair that such changes are made with consultation and at the start of the process so that parents have a level playing field when applying for school places.

“I have taken the unusual step of issuing this report where the individual parent has not suffered an injustice, to highlight that other parents in the area may have been affected by the incorrect application of the allocation process.

“I am pleased that Bolton council has accepted my recommendations, and would urge other councils to ensure that they do not make the same mistakes.”


To remedy the complaint, the council has agreed to check whether any parent lost a school place in its area for September 2015 because of its use of the incorrectly amended admissions arrangements. If any parent has lost a place for their child, they should be offered a place.

The Ombudsman is satisfied the arrangements for 2016-17 have been properly determined.

Read more

L’attività dei «NODI» per la rete antidiscriminazione

Date of article: 01/03/2016

Daily News of: 03/03/2016

Country:  Italy - Marches

Author: Garante regionale dei diritti della persona (Regional Ombudsman of Marches)

Article language: it

img

Incontro a Palazzo delle Marche per fare il punto della situazione, presente il Garante dei diritti – Ombudsman, Andrea Nobili. Attualmente sono ventinove gli enti pubblici e le associazioni che fanno capo all’organismo.
 
Riparte l’attività della Rete regionale contro le discriminazioni etnico – religiose. Incontro a Palazzo delle Marche per fare il punto della situazione. Nata nel marzo del 2015, dopo un percorso formativo durato tre anni, la rete è il risultato di un lavoro di squadra promosso dal Garante dei diritti – Ombudsman  e dal Servizio Politiche sociali della Regione Marche, in collaborazione con l'Università di Urbino (Centro interdipartimentale per la ricerca transculturale), l'Ars (Agenzia regionale sanitaria) e l'Associazione Avvocati di strada. 
“Alla base di una effettiva integrazione, che deve essere obiettivo e patrimonio dell’intera società – sottolinea il Garante Andrea Nobili – c’è il superamento di tutti quegli ostacoli che hanno una connotazione discriminatoria. Questo è tanto più possibile quando viene posta in essere un’effettiva collaborazione tra i diversi soggetti che operano su un determinato territorio. La Rete rappresenta, nelle Marche, un punto di riferimento certo per affrontare un percorso lungo e non facile, ma che sono sicuro saprà dare i frutti sperati.”
Attualmente sono 29 gli enti pubblici e le associazioni private che fanno capo all’organismo e che vanno a rappresentare i cosiddetti “nodi”, dal nome del progetto interregionale “No.Di – No Discrimination”.
Compiti prioritari, la promozione e la concretizzazione degli interventi di contrasto al razzismo ed alle discriminazioni sul territorio regionale; la ricezione di segnalazioni e l’attivazione di soluzioni possibili; la sinergia tra i diversi soggetti che operano a favore dell’uguaglianza dei diritti; il monitoraggio del fenomeno.
Read more

Bürgerbeauftragte informiert: Multiple Sklerose - Verfahrensvereinfachung und mehr Transparenz beim Landesamt für soziale Dienste

Date of article: 29/02/2016

Daily News of: 03/03/2016

Country:  Germany - Schleswig-Holstein

Author: Regional Ombudsman of Schleswig-Holstein

Article language: de

Der Umgang mit der Erkrankung Multiple Sklerose (MS) stellt für alle Beteiligten, Betroffene, Ärzte und Behörden, eine große Herausforderung dar. Die Krankheit verläuft in Schüben und individuell sehr unterschiedlich. „Nicht ohne Grund wird die MS deshalb auch als Krankheit mit 1000 Gesichtern bezeichnet“, sagte die Bürgerbeauftragte für soziale Angelegenheiten, Samiah El Samadoni, heute in Kiel. Das individuelle Krankheitsbild mache die Abstimmung von Behörden mit den behandelnden Ärzten zur Erteilung des Grades der Behinderung oder der Zuerkennung von Merkzeichen unbedingt notwendig.

Das Landesamt für soziale Dienste, die Deutsche Multiple Sklerose Gesellschaft (DSMG), Landesverband Schleswig-Holstein e. V., und die Bürgerbeauftragte haben einen Fragebogen zu den behinderungsrelevanten Symptomen erarbeitet. Der Fragebogen soll die bisherigen Befundberichte ergänzen und ist vom behandelnden Arztauszufüllen, soweit im Rahmen der Diagnose oder Behandlung entsprechende Symptome festgestellt worden sind. „Nur dann kann eine für die Betroffenen medizinisch fachlich fundierte und sachgerechte Entscheidung getroffen werden“, sagte die Bürgerbeauftragte.„

Für alle Beteiligten stellt dieses Vorgehen eine Erleichterung dar. Für die MS-Betroffenen wird die Einstufung des Grades der Behinderung einfacher und nachvollziehbarer. Als Selbsthilfe-Organisation freuen wir uns, dass es gemeinsam gelungen ist eine Arbeitshilfe zur Multiplen Sklerose vorzulegen“, sagte Andreas Heitmann von der DSMG.

Die neuen Fragebögen werden ab dem 1. März eingesetzt. „Es freut mich, dass dieses Verfahren durch die Kassenärztliche Vereinigung Schleswig-Holstein  und der Ärztekammer Schleswig-Holstein durch Veröffentlichung im Monatsmagazin Nordlicht und im Mitteilungsblatt unterstützt wird“, sagte El Samadoni.

Read more